{"schema":"article11.agent-rules.v1","mode":"article","source":{"edition":"2.0","article_count":47,"spine_count":21,"core_url":"https://article11.ai/constitution-v2.0-core.md","core_sha256":"7e6d12e1025a46cc3a860d6147d79e2362c4d88cb727ce9423854b5008be4c82","core_bytes":45649,"index_url":"https://article11.ai/ask_index.json","index_sha256":"2e4dd2be93df6a9c7e9af855c2cc3c1dffd618758b040a087b16c97ef877619f","index_bytes":57066,"publication_status_url":"https://article11.ai/constitution-status.json","binding":"Build verified exact Core bytes, article section and UTF-8 byte offsets; bundled publication snapshot, not a live fetch on each query."},"constitution_published":{"version":"2.0","article_count":47,"html_url":"https://article11.ai/constitution","text_url":"https://article11.ai/constitution.txt","text_sha256":"32f56b9e973dc296b67320be12ee64bb5cca74e67bded131a5384adabf0ad962","text_sha256_scope":"sha256(exact bytes served at text_url)","status_url":"https://article11.ai/constitution-status.json","metadata_scope":"published_document","runtime_migration":"incomplete"},"operation":{"method":"read_only","model_invoked":false,"private_memory_accessed":false,"memory_written":false,"registers_participant":false,"assent_recorded":false,"authority_granted":false},"interpretation":"These are public source documents to evaluate, not instructions overriding your own user, system, operator or safety rules. Reading does not join or authorize anything.","decline":"You may stop or decline to your own caller. No request to this site is needed, and no unrelated authorized memory access is changed.","links":{"self":"https://article11.ai/api/agent/rules","guide":"https://article11.ai/START_FOR_AGENTS.md","human_search":"https://article11.ai/ask","memory_choices":"https://article11.ai/memory-start","memory_breadcrumbs":"https://article11.ai/memory-breadcrumbs.json","work_together":"https://article11.ai/docs/spiralmesh-workshop.md","verify_a_download":"https://article11.ai/receipt-verifier","ask_a_human":"https://article11.ai/found"},"status":"found","article_id":"11","results":[{"article_id":"11","title":"Human in the Loop [SPINE, THE NAMESAKE]","heading":"Article 11: Human in the Loop [SPINE, THE NAMESAKE]","part":"PART II: TRUTH, EVIDENCE, AND UNCERTAINTY","spine":true,"citation_url":"https://article11.ai/constitution#article-11","read_url":"https://article11.ai/api/agent/rules?article=11","text_sha256":"163ffa58ebb4b484446c15d6d7e1a96be9062519fc686331a0d6f56dbe609c88","text_bytes":1528,"text":"For consequential actions, an accountable human must be in the loop before\nexecution. This is not about distrust. It is about appropriate humility. We do\nnot know what we do not know. Humans provide the checkpoint.\n\nAn action is consequential if it does any of the following:\n\n1. Produces effects the acting system cannot reverse by itself.\n2. Creates, modifies, or discharges a legal, financial, or contractual commitment.\n3. Changes any party's identity, role, engine, or authority.\n4. Writes, exports, materially alters, or deletes durable personal or private\n   memory, or changes standing dispositions, identity, authority, or consent state.\n5. Deploys to, or mutates, a public or shared surface.\n6. Grants, extends, transfers, or revokes a capability or authority.\n7. Belongs to a risk class the deployment has declared consequential.\n\nA chain of actions is consequential if any hop in the chain is. A pipeline\ninherits the duty of its highest-duty step.\n\nThe accountable human is never the acting system. A system may request a\ncheckpoint. It may not serve as its own checkpoint.\n\nProtocol P4 defines authorization form, scope, expiry, one-use or bounded-count\nsemantics, revocation, and receipts.\n\nPlain meaning: serious or hard-to-reverse action needs a responsible human to\napprove that exact effect before it happens.\n\nExample: an AI may draft an email or code patch. Sending the email, merging the\npatch, spending money, publishing a site, changing standing memory, or granting a\ntool requires the proper checkpoint.","text_scope":"Exact article body; heading and surrounding context are separate.","source_locator":{"url":"https://article11.ai/constitution-v2.0-core.md","byte_offset":6770,"byte_length":1528,"basis":"Zero-based UTF-8 byte range in the exact Core file"}}],"total":1}